Cake Creations in New Carlisle

The donuts and cookies were great, and the employees very nice 🤓

Boston cream cupcake. Do I need to say anything else? Awesome.

Absolutely delicious!! The owners are so nice too!!

My family and I frequent this place when we need cupcakes or a cake for any event. Or for just a sweet tooth! The women in the store are WONDERFUL. And as sweet as their creations. The best cupcakes I've ever had ♡

I stopped by today after years of wanting to but never stopping. This place did NOT disappoint. So many things to choose from, so many flavors that you don't see at other bakeries, and the prices were amazing too. I got a sugar cookie (delicious) and a banana split cupcake (who would've thought of this),... OMG!!! ❤️❤️ I am in love. The whole thing was perfection , the most, soft cake, the sweet but not too sweet icing, and the chocolate drizzle through the icing, not to mention the cream inside. The perfect banana cake with strawberry and chocolate. My only regret is not getting 2 of these. I will be going back very very soon. Do not miss out, try this place. You will not regret it

Nice little bakery. Delicious cupcakes and cookies.

Love the service, cake and great prices.

Everything always delicious 😋

Amazing place! We order every cake for every occasion here. Nicest people, beautiful cakes, and fair prices. Highly recommend!

Have used Cake Creations over the years because their cakes are delicious and unique! Thank you for another great birthday!

Beautiful cupcakes. Delicious donuts.

Delicious cake and desserts.... My daughter loved her unicorn cake!

AMAZING, everything I've tried from here is nothing short of amazing!

The best bakery around!

Friendly staff! Opened the door for us even though we were early and their food was amazing as well!

So many options! Their cupcakes are AMAZING❤ Highly recommend having milk to go with your sweet tooth ;)

Amazing never dry cakes with the best iceing ever, cup cakes, basically anything you want Brooke can make it happen awesome job Ladies. Say you want a cake and you want it to be made out of cup cakes, Cake Creations is the place to go. Done all of mine

They did an outstanding job on my daughter's birthday cake!! It was beautiful!

I come for doughnuts in the mornings and cupcakes in the evening. Always great food and smiling faces.

Did an amazing job on wedding cake and cupcakes!’ Was everything and more of what we asked for! Everything was beautiful and delicious!! Highly recommend!!!

Great cakes and donuts but the cupcakes are my absolute favorite! We enjoy getting a variety of flavors - fun and delicious!

Such delicious donuts. Tasted wonderful.

Great place to get cupcakes or a specialty cake. Get there early if you want donuts. Also the cookies are AWESOME.

They did an absolute wonderful job on our wedding cake and cupcakes as well! I highly recommend them! They are beyond caring and professional! Keep up the great work! Ive been telling everyone great things about you!

My customers love it when I bring them goodies from here. Great selection and taste

My family has always gone there for our special occasion needs, well not anymore. We ordered my cake and cupcakes for my wedding there and not only was the quality of the decorated cake terrible but the customer service was awful. The lady ended up throwing money at me and yelling at me to “get out and just leave!” I ended up having to run around the day before my wedding to find a cake. Myself and my husband to be were unhappy with the cake and were overly nice and willing to come to a compromise but the woman was more than unwilling to even discuss it. She just became very rude and belligerent about the situation. Ive had friends since that incident tell me they’ve encountered similar situations there unfortunately. I wouldn’t recommend anyone go there.

Everything that I've had here is amazing. Specifically their oatmeal cookies and pumpkin cookies are the best I've ever had. I also ordered a German chocolate cake for the holidays that was as good as I've had. The owner is very helpful and nice. This is now the only place I go for baked goods.

I have gotten three cakes from them now and they have yet to disappoint me they are amazing and the best cakes you could ever taste they can do pretty much anything you want and are not very expensive and not to mention the staff there is so polite i highly recommend them to everyone!!

I love their cakes and friendly service!

Lemon cupcakes, when available/fresh items.

Cake Creations made beautiful, fun and tasty cup cakes for my daughter's shower. Exactly what I asked for!

Local bakery, friendly people, awesome 👍 👍👍 👍

This is literally the best cake I have ever eaten in my life. Like, I'm not even joking. This place is amazing! I HIGHLY recommend getting cakes from here. They are just incredible!

They have the best cookies cakes Cupcakes around Clark County

Great doughnuts.. but they run out pretty fast... Buckeyes are good... And the service is awesome

Great selection of delicious donuts, cupcakes & cookies!!

Quaint little place I discovered while driving around. You cannot miss the place - it's a neon pink building! That just adds to it. The do cakes, cookies, donuts and cupcakes at what seem to be decent prices. They had a wide array of cupcake flavors. I got several. They were all moist and very flavorful - some almost to the point of too sweet. Well worth the stop if you ever happen upon them at the corner of Rts. 235 & 40.

Cream puffs are so good

Stopped in for a birthday cake, it was delicious and it was decorated just the way I wanted

Love the cakes. Not to sweet. Special orders.

I love their cupcakes and great personal service

These ladies know how to make great donuts, cookies and muffins. I haven't bought a thing here that wasnt amazing. My wife begs me NOT to stop here because she knows if I bring home a dozen cookies they will be gone before bed time.

Nice people . Pastrys taste great.

Such a cute sweet little bakery!There are so many things to choose from, you won't know what to pick. They have cookies, brownies, donuts and more. My favorite are the cupcakes. Just about any flavor you can think of will be here, and at only $1.00 a cupcake? You just can't beat that. I highly suggest this place to everyone and I definitely plan many return visits.

Stopped here for a cupcake while on an Ohio TuesDayTrips event down Historic National Road. Delicious and priced right.

Very good cupcakes.

Beautiful cake, amazingly moist, great taste. Good price. Thank you!

Tasted ok. Small portions and very poor selection unless you like cupcakes. To expensive for what you get

Love their cakes, cupcakes and cookies!

Their cookies are delicious. They have a lot of beautiful selection. The work is there. I was understanding with the first few times the employees acted aloof and angry towards me. I didn't take it personally until I realized it was every single time I went the that they acted the same. I didn't feel welcome, so I stopped going.